Comparisons of "AI video tools" usually put four products in the same bucket when they do two different jobs. Runway and Pika generate footage, meaning shots and scenes that didn't exist before. HeyGen and Synthesia generate a presenter: a talking avatar that reads a script you wrote. If you pick from the wrong pair, no pricing tier will save you. So first figure out which job you have, then look at the credit math, because all four bill in units that don't map neatly to "videos."
◆ This is an affiliate link — if you sign up, it may earn Ai DigiSphere a commission at no extra cost to you. See our disclosure.
Two jobs hiding under one label
Generative video means you describe or upload something and get a short clip back, like a product shot, a b-roll moment, or a stylized social loop. You're paying for seconds, and retries cost the same as keepers.
Avatar video means you paste a script, pick a presenter and a language, and get a talking-head video for training, sales outreach, or internal updates. You're paying for minutes, and the output is fairly predictable.
If you need both (say, an explainer with a presenter cutting to b-roll), plan on two subscriptions. None of these four does both jobs well.
Runway: the generative workhorse, priced by the second
Runway's plan structure is simple. Its pricing page lists $0 on Free (125 one-time credits), $15 a month on Standard ($12 billed yearly) for 625 credits, $35 on Pro ($28 yearly) for 2,250, and $95 on Max ($76 yearly) for 9,500. The catch is how quickly credits run out. Gen-4.5 uses 12 credits per second of generated video, so Standard's monthly pool gets you roughly 52 seconds of top-model footage. One independent breakdown found that five accepted Gen-4.5 shots at two attempts each already consume 600 of its 625 monthly credits.
Credits behave differently by tier. Standard and Pro monthly credits do not roll over and reset within 24 hours of each billing date; Max rolls over up to one month of unused credits, and purchased credits never expire. The free tier is for testing only: it comes with watermarked videos, no credit purchases.
Pick Runway if you need cinematic shots for ads, music videos, or product reels and you'll spend real time choosing between retries. Budget for Pro if you make video every week. Standard is a sampler.
Pika: cheaper entry, and a new app worth rechecking
Pika changed a lot this fall. Pika relaunched in September 2026 as one platform for video, image and sound. Current plans are Starter at $10, Creator at $35, and Fancy from $95 a month when billed monthly (about 20% less on annual billing). Credits are pooled: all of them draw from one monthly credit balance that works across every model.
Older reviews describe a different free tier. After the relaunch, the free plan has no monthly credits, runs on purchased credit packs only, and exports carry no watermark but come without a commercial license. Sources disagree on which paid tier first includes commercial rights. One says commercial licensing starts at Creator, $35/month, and another names the $10 Starter. Check Pika's current terms before you publish client work with it. Also note that plan credits refresh each billing period and do not roll over, while top-up credits expire after a year.
Pick Pika if you make short, vertical, playful social content and want cheap monthly entry. Reviewers keep pointing to its effects library as the reason to choose it. One verdict calls it worth it if you make short, vertical, social-first video and want the Pikaffects that no other tool replicates well.
HeyGen vs Synthesia: two avatar tools with different priorities
Both turn a script into a presenter video, but they're tuned for different buyers.
HeyGen is built for creators and marketers who want volume and many languages. Its pricing page lists Free at $0 (3 videos a month, up to 1 minute each), Creator at $29 a month or $24 a month billed annually with 600 credits, Pro from $49 a month for 1,000 credits, and Business at $149/mo Business, plus $20 per extra seat. How far your credits go depends on the avatar model. Avatar IV and V -- the photorealistic avatar quality everyone actually wants -- costs 20 credits per minute. That works out to about 30 minutes a month on Creator. On team plans, extra seats do not add credits, so the whole team draws from one pool.
Synthesia is aimed at companies making training and internal video. Its prices are harder to pin down because they vary by region. The standard list is $29 a month, or $18 a month billed yearly. Pro, the plan previously called Creator, costs $89 a month, or $64 a month billed yearly. But in Synthesia's US price card on October 26, 2026, Basic is free, Starter costs $14 per month billed yearly or $19 monthly, and Pro starts at $59 per month billed yearly. Check what the page shows you. Usage is more consistent: a standard minute of avatar video uses about 100 credits, and every plan includes 10 free minutes of video or dubbing each month. The features that matter to L&D teams, like SCORM export and SSO, are mostly on Enterprise.
The headline numbers differ too. One comparison lists HeyGen's language coverage as 175+ languages and dialects on paid plans, against Synthesia's 140+. On unused credits, Synthesia's reset every billing period, while HeyGen's roll over for a month.
Pick HeyGen if you're one person or a small marketing team pushing out multilingual social clips, sales videos, or translated versions of existing footage. Pick Synthesia if you're building a training library that has to fit a company's compliance and LMS setup.
How to choose in five minutes
Answer these in order:
- Do you need a person talking to camera? If yes, choose HeyGen or Synthesia. If no, choose Runway or Pika.
- Is it for social or for the company? Social, short, and stylized points to Pika or HeyGen. Polished, branded, or internal points to Runway or Synthesia.
- How many retries will you burn? For generative tools, plan on paying for at least twice the seconds you keep. We explain how credit pools hide this in our breakdown of credits vs subscriptions.
- Do you need commercial rights today? Confirm on the vendor's own terms page, especially for Pika after its relaunch.
- Start monthly, not annual. All four discount yearly billing, and all four have changed prices or plan names in 2026. Pay monthly until you know your real usage.
All prices above are as reported in October–November 2026 and change often. Check Runway, Pika, HeyGen, and Synthesia before you commit.
FAQ
Which AI video tool is cheapest to start with?
By sticker price, Pika's $10 Starter plan is the cheapest monthly entry of the four. For real testing, though, HeyGen's free tier (three short watermarked videos a month) and Runway's 125 one-time credits let you try the output without paying anything. Pika's free plan now needs a credit pack before you can generate.
Can Runway or Pika make a talking presenter video?
Not in the way HeyGen and Synthesia do. Runway and Pika generate scenes and motion. They aren't built to deliver a scripted presenter with accurate lip-sync over several minutes. If your video is mostly someone explaining something, use an avatar tool and add generative b-roll separately.
Is HeyGen or Synthesia better for training videos?
Synthesia is the more natural fit for corporate training, because its top tier is built around things like SCORM export and SSO that LMS-driven teams need. HeyGen is usually the better choice for marketing, outreach, and translating videos into many languages, and its Creator plan gives a solo user more avatar minutes for the money.
Start your free trial → ◆ Affiliate link — see our disclosure.